By Michael Nagler
Note from Stephanie: No tigers were harmed, even in reputation, in the sharing of this article. It’s a terrible problem the way that humans frame other animals or even weather as violent, when violence emerges from us, and it is in us that we have to heal it.
THEY ARE EVERYWHERE. Wherever you drive in this part of the world (Marin County), you are presented—no, assaulted—by billboards announcing “Law Tigers” and, in case you miss the point, the slogan is flanked by the large, realistic, snarling face of a tiger. The point? We will help you win! Savage the other guy.
The underlying assumption here is that law is a fight. Win or lose. Almost literally, the law of the jungle. I have never accepted the idea that lawyers or doctors (or professors) should advertise, and perhaps that a noble profession in principle should have to stoop to an image of crude savagery shows I was right.
Gandhi, remember, was a lawyer! Having failed in Indian law courts, he seized upon the humbler position offered him to go to South Africa to represent an Indian firm ‘for a year.’ That year, of course, turned into 21. But it did not take him 21 years to discover the purpose of law: that was “to unite parties riven asunder.” The contrast could not be more extreme.
Doctors heal patients; lawyers heal relationships, eventually society. Socrates said that every occupation had its legitimate purpose, which can be corrupted when it’s thought of primarily as a way to get rich. From that reduction, we proceed inevitably to the deepest corruption, on billboard wisdom: benefit yourself by hurting others. The Hippocratic mantra is primum non nocere, ‘first (principle), do no harm.’ The same value should be the standard held aloft by the law; for that matter, for education and, yes, business. Everything.
This degradation has serious consequences, for underneath the specific assumption that law is a fight (not to mention what’s happened to elections!) lies the more general assumption that life is a fight. We are separate beings; the basic mode of existence is competition, which, carried to its logical conclusion, becomes violence.
This has never been the vision of our wisest people. Think of Einstein:
A human being is part of the whole, called by us “universe,” a part limited in time and space. He experiences himself, his thoughts and feelings, as something separate from the rest—a kind of optical delusion of consciousness. This delusion is a kind of prison for us, restricting us to our personal desires and to affection for a few persons nearest to us. Our task must be to free ourselves from this prison by widening our circle of compassion to embrace all living creatures and the whole of nature in its beauty.
The great scientist is giving specific spiritual content here to the Jewish sages’ concept that what we call creation was actually zimzum, a drastic ‘contraction’ of Reality; a contraction that the individual human being, uniquely in creation, can re-expand or overcome. There are two ways to go about this. First, case by case (no pun intended), we can simply will not to see ourselves as in competition with, say, someone with whom we have a disagreement, but rather as a partner in the cooperative effort to restore balance, justice. Society-wide, we can shift to practices like mediation and, instead of punishment, to restorative justice. These are both well-developed institutions in use the world over.
Second, we can teach, ‘by any means necessary’—formal education, the media, our personal conversations—the truth that emerges at the meeting point of ancient wisdom and modern quantum science: that Reality is One (as the Jewish sages taught, ein sof). Consciousness, which Max Planck correctly identified as the fundamental reality, is indivisible and eternal. I think it was Meister Eckhart who said, ‘You were originally unlimited. You took on limitations [zimzum again] and became mind.’ And as Einstein says, by the power of mind we can reverse that limitation. Everything from physics to peace can be grounded in that reality.
I started with law, not because it’s the worst or the only example, but simply because it’s ‘in our face’ wherever we drive. And because it would be, as Gandhi showed, a grand place to start the renewal of community.